Why sell bicycle light brackets?

[Edited again to add: I now think I was wrong in what I said in this post, but it continues to be among my most-read posts. I have left it here because I don't want to appear to be hiding the fact that I have changed my mind about this]

[Note: after a number of helpful comments (see below) I have revised my opinion about this. Please continue to use Evans Cycles as you see fit :-)] 

Consider a typical bicycle light. It’s a small battery-powered light, easily fits in a pocket and just as easily dropped or lost. It unclips easily from its mounting bracket so you can take it with you when you leave the bike.

So there are two components to your typical bicycle light: the light itself and the bracket attached to the bike. Which do you think is most likely to need replacing? The fragile light that you are constantly transferring from place to place, or the sturdy bracket that never leaves its secure attachment to the bicycle?

Don’t make the question harder than it sounds. The correct answer is the obvious one. Ninety-nine times out of a hundred you will lose or break the light before the bracket needs replacing.

Can you, therefore, go to a cycle shop and buy a replacement light for your bracket? Don’t be silly, of course you can’t. Can you, on the other hand, go to a cycle shop and buy a replacement bracket for your lamp? Why yes! How fortunate! For that one time out of a hundred when (I don’t know) a heavy piece of street furniture snaps off and smashes your bracket, yes, you can go to the cycle shop and get a new one.

That must be why the cycle shops carry so much stock of brackets. All those bits of heavy street furniture that are constantly breaking off and smashing light brackets all over the place.

Or perhaps its because the FUCKERS who STEAL lights off unattended bicycles can go in and get a cheap replacement bracket to attach the STOLEN lights to their own, probably STOLEN, bicycles.

Do not buy stuff from any bicycle shop that stocks replacement brackets. Evans Cycles, this means you for a start. Any others?

13 Responses to “Why sell bicycle light brackets?”


  1. 1 Anonymous November 20, 2005 at 2:58 pm

    Err, Dominic I have 4 bikes that’s why they sell replacement brackets as well as for breakages.

    I also built a set of high powered lights and adapted a standard bracket for this purpose.–>

  2. 2 Eric June 17, 2006 at 6:02 am

    Sure wish I had a bike shop at all to go to…. come to Korea where everything in the world is made, but they don’t sell the crap here because if you are riding a bicycle you are probably delivering chickens to the market.

  3. 3 Emmy December 13, 2006 at 5:28 pm

    I recently had my bike stolen. Just the bike. With the brackets attatched. So now I have 2 lights but no brackets. Sadly evans only have cateye brackets. I have some crappy old lights made by powerbeam - probably in Korea. But i do see what you mean, the number of lights i’ve been through in a lifetime is many….

  4. 4 mike January 4, 2007 at 3:29 pm

    Or when you leave the bracket on your bike and some comedy genius steals the bracket that you walk away from

  5. 5 Scott in Chicago January 25, 2007 at 6:12 pm

    Yesterday I dropped my bike while putting on my helmet. The light bracket broke but the light itself did not. Now I have a light that I can’t mount on a bike.

    Should we let a few bad eggs spoil it for the rest of us? You would have me bear the cost of a new light & bracket set-up to thwart the potential for future theft. Maybe I will resort to duct tape!

  6. 6 nodney July 15, 2007 at 8:02 pm

    Had my bike stole two weeks ago. I have something like £100 of lights for it. The lights were in my bag, nice and safe. The brackets were spiritied away along with the bike. Evans sells the brackets. Thank you them for saving me a heap of cash.

  7. 7 Frogstar August 22, 2007 at 8:29 pm

    Had my bike stolen, need cateye replacement brackets

    I will look up the evans cycles

    Thankyou

  8. 8 rich October 12, 2007 at 1:19 am

    Well that wasn’t well thought out, was it. Please think before making suggestions to punish those providing a useful service.

    Like others out there with a bit of experience, I
    i) just had a bike stolen with three brackets on it
    ii) had my lights safely esconced
    iii) don’t want to buy new cateye lights
    and
    iv) before stolen had three bikes and just one set of lights, so extra brackets were already required.

  9. 9 Dominic Sayers October 12, 2007 at 9:55 am

    I think the weight of evidence is against me here. As John Maynard Keynes said, “When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?”

    I’m going to add a note to the original post.

  10. 10 Dominic Sayers January 23, 2008 at 3:45 pm

    And the final nail in the coffin of this post is that I went to Evans today to buy a new bracket for a light I had. The original bike was stolen but I still had the light.

  11. 11 Martin July 8, 2008 at 9:36 am

    Certainly Evan’s Cycles in the City are a good bunch; when my saddle and post was nicked yesterday they gave me a spare saddle for free.

  12. 12 Catherine York July 28, 2008 at 9:51 pm

    Yeah, well, I don’t often go out on my bike after dark. Tonight I needed to, so I got my cat-eye lights, put the front one into its bracket and then turned my attention to the back one. Imagine how I felt when I realised there WAS NO BRACKET THERE AAAAAAAAAARRRRRGHHHHHHHHH!! Some f*cker had only nicked the blasted bracket!!! Had to go out with front light alone. Good job I have a reflective vizzy jacket…

    So, I for one, am glad you can buy replacement brackets…wonder if I’ll be able to get one that isn’t so easy to nick? These ones don’t even require you to have a screwdriver in order to put them on - OR TAKE THEM OFF!!!

  13. 13 Dominic Sayers July 29, 2008 at 8:44 am

    Thanks Catherine. I’ve changed my mind about this (which is why I put the note at the top of the post). I don’t believe in censoring what I wrote do I have left the post in place but I am no longer angry about this :-)

    There are clearly a number of sound reasons why the brackets might be sold separately. I was wrong.

Leave a Reply




Introduction

Share me

Add to Technorati Favorites

Dominic's photographs

DSC_0074

Appearing Rooms fountains, Southbank Centre

St Paul's Cathedral

St Paul's Cathedral

More Photos